Diversity is not new to the Western World, despite the claims made by the Left and the Oligarchy. It has been a core component of the social fabric of a huge swathe of the West – namely, Latin America. Today, its supporters and its foes should take a close look at this experiment and see what they can learn from it. It is time to send envoys to the tropics, not to conquer the land but to understand its people. They must ask these questions: How is it that diversity is a source of unity, not dislocation, in this part of the West? And how is it that poverty within and diplomatic insignificance without are accepted as part of the natural order? Because the budget is tight, let’s take a deep dive into the most advanced diversity lab of the world: Brazil.
Brazil is multiracial but not multicultural. There is one civilisation in place from Manaus in the north to Porto Alegre in the South. Nowhere is Brazilian civilisation challenged. The only exception is the way of life of a very small minority of indigenous people – up to ten thousand nationwide – who refuse protracted contact with the authorities and the outside world. These não contatados hide in the rain forest and do not want to convert anyone to their civilization. They can only aspire to be a relic. In other words, Brazil is much more homogeneous (and lucky) than Europe, which has become home to two rival civilizations: the West and Islam. And unlike the Indians of the Amazon, the Muslims of Europe are neither weak nor peripheral.
Throughout the land, one is in the presence of a single religious ethos: Christianity. Brazil is the son of Christ. Whatever the colour of his skin, he cares about Mary and he feels he comes from Bethlehem. Brazil is a spiritual unity. And, probably most important, Brazil speaks Portuguese and only Portuguese. Brazil is a country of one single idiom which unites different DNAs whenever they need to think, dream, or make love. This goes beyond grammar and vocabulary; it speaks of an organic and unbreakable connexion with the Mediterranean. If Americans feel they are the inheritors of Rome or Athens, the Brazilians represent an improved breed of Mediterraneans, one capable of colonizing the swamps of Mato Grosso and resisting hyperinflation. One capable of building an empire covering several ecosystems and keeping it united and coherent. A nation of Robinson Crusoes isolated from one another by an ocean of land, but keeping faith in a common destiny. The Brazilian never gives up, however hard times may be.
Under the supervision of the Portuguese, the Brazilian melting pot blended the Indians, the Blacks and the Europeans into a single civilization that thought and felt Mediterranean. Whether Brazilians are Yoruba black or Danish white, their soul is irrigated by the emotions and the mindsets of the peoples of southern Europe: Portugal, of course, but also Spain, and especially Italy.
In a way, Brazil is a succursal of Italy that speaks Portuguese. Outside Italy, Brazil is the country where one finds the highest number of Italians. Over 30 million Brazilians have an Italian ancestor and one third of the population of the city of São Paulo share Italian blood.
In the late 19th century, 1.4 million Italians (mainly from the South) and 700,000 Spaniards landed in Brazil. Combined with the Portuguese, these latinos reached a critical mass and made the decisive impact on the Brazilian soul at a time it was desperately looking for an identity other than colonial. Back then, the country was composed of a white ruling elite facing black and indigenous masses. The newcomers changed the course of history and gave the Brazilian blend its Mediterranean flavour, which endures to this day. The Italian input seems to have left a stronger impression than the Spanish one – more by virtue of demographics than because the Italians speak louder. Other groups came in virtually at the same time or slightly after, like the Germans, the Japanese and the Arabs, but their numbers were less significant. They were assimilated by the Mediterraneans, who set the tone – culturally, aesthetically and morally.
As a result, the ‘motor’ of the Brazilian soul is fuelled by the waters of the Mediterranean Sea: family and religion are fundamental; private violence is licit; interpersonal relations are viewed as a protection against the accidents of life, and thus are constantly promoted; feudality is present, as one is always looking for a ‘patrão’ to protect and feed one; and the State is inefficient – and this is also fine, as a public manager is not assessed by his performance but by the level of happiness of his clientele.
This synthesis is colour-blind. Even if half of the population is black, the Mediterranean character is primordial. The black Brazilian is a latino with a dark skin. He has the same admirable qualities and the same irritating limitations as the yellow, the white, the Indian and the Arab Brazilians.
This miracle was made possible by another fundamental feature of Brazilian diversity: racial mixture. Unlike the Anglo-Saxons, the Portuguese sought intercourse with women of colour (Black or Indian) and built a new race with their offspring. The other immigrants (Italians, Germans, Russians, Arabs etc.) followed the pattern set by the Portuguese out of imitation but also admiration for the values of the ruling elites. Even the Japanese immigrants have slackened their ethnic endogamy, which means a lot for a group usually attached to its singularity.
All Brazilians are aware of their racial mixture. They know they ‘come from another planet’ when compared to North Americans or Chinese. They are neither proud nor ashamed of it; they just want to keep it as it is. This unique feature is at the core of the Brazilian identity and gives its people a sense of unity. Brazilians are united by their diversity.
Already, one can draw some lessons for Europe’s current experiment in diversity. Brazil shows that it is a bottom-up mechanism. People go to bed together first; they make children; and then they build a diverse society. No law or subsidy is required. Moreover, diversity was a prerequisite for building a huge country, fuelling a political process that consisted of creating enough people to occupy and use the land – and to survive to its diseases and perils. Is Europe facing a similar challenge today? What new planet are the Europeans about to conquer?
However, even a people of mixed blood are not immune to racism. For whenever there is a difference, there is a pretext for acrimony. Subtility is the other name of racism in Brazil. It is never far away but it is mild and it never takes the path of apartheid. Racism flirts with the belief that the less dark one becomes, the better one is. Japanese can marry Italians in Brazil but their sons may look down on Blacks. They may date a mulatto (half-black, half-white) but they will be reluctant to have a black gynaecologist look at their wife’s uterus. In general, the darker the skin is, the poorer one is. But poverty is not limited to the blacks. I spent a month in a favela of Rio de Janeiro where the inhabitants were predominantly white.
The key to the correction of racial inequalities in Brazil is not racial. Brazil lacks the economic dynamism to lift its population from underdevelopment. It is underpowered – that is the real Brazilian tragedy that no government wishes to tackle nor to understand.
As a matter of fact, Brazilian civilisation is outdated because its mission is no longer necessary. It fabricated improved Mediterraneans in order to conquer a vast and perilous land, not to produce a high value per capita. Brazilians are not Swiss or Koreans. They made an empire, ill-managed from north to south, not a nation-state run by top-notch bureaucrats. Brazilians are not French or Germans. A new set of values (i.e. moral qualities) is required: more transparency and less corruption, more efficiency and less nepotism, more innovation and less attachment to failed solutions that have been proven wrong everywhere else in the world – like socialism and excessive bureaucracy.
Not all values must be thrown away. Resiliency must be preserved, dynamism also, optimism for sure. But a new blend is required to provide Brazil with a world-class identity.
It is very difficult for the Brazilians to acknowledge this and to act upon it. They are blinded to the evidence. Socialism taught them to forget about mindsets and values, and to focus only on wealth redistribution. Liberalism got them used to ignoring systemic corruption and ultra violence, two mortal enemies of GDP growth. The liberals don’t get it that homo economicus cannot flourish among stray bullets. It is a shame Adam Smith was not born in Rio de Janeiro – a war zone.
The future of Brazil depends on the way it will ‘manage’ its diversity. Thoughtful engineers are needed, ones that can reorganize the soul of a people. Maybe the moment has come to make better use of the African and Indian elements of the melting pot. Maybe there are seeds in there whose cultivation will help free Brazil from its plagues. The Mediterranean moment has probably passed, and needs to give way to something better, stronger and brighter.
This is the role of elites, as Toynbee would say. Transforming diversity into power and excellence must be the new mission of the Brazilian elite. Otherwise, they will keep flying once a year to Miami to watch the wonders of Anglo-Saxon governance applied to a Latin people on a tropical soil.
Originally published in The Salisbury Review.


Leave a Comment